PPV vs Phacovitrectomy for RRD in Phakic Eyes

Vaidehi Dedania, MD; Yewlin Chee, MD; and Joshua Uhr, MD

Show Description +

Does phacovitrectomy improve outcomes over conventional PPV for rhegmatogenous retinal detachment repair in a phakic eyes? Or does it introduce unnecessary complexity? Vaidehi Dedania, MD; Yewlin Chee, MD; and Joshua Uhr, MD, review results from a multicenter cohort study published in Ophthalmology Retina and discuss whether the study's findings have any bearing on real-world decision-making, parse generational differences regarding perceived phacovitrectomy risks, and review whether changes to technology during the course of the study may have affected the findings.

Posted: 10/14/2026

Keywords:

phacovitrectomy

•

PPV

•

RRD

•

Phakic

•

New Retina Radio Journal Club

Up Next

Vitreous Hemorrhage Following PVD: Who Needs Surgery?

Barton Blackorby, MD, Matt Starr, MD, and Kyle Kovacs, MD

Comparing Ocular AEs in Next-Gen Treatments

Katherine Talcott, MD; Akshay Thomas, MD; and Nita Valikodath, MD, MS

Clinical Features and Outcomes of IOFB Removal

Jordan Deaner, MD, Vaidehi Dedania, MD, and Rehan Hussain, MD

Retinal Perfusion, Sensitivity, and Function in DR

Barton Blackorby, MD; Katherine Talcott, MD; and Hong-Uyen Hua, MD

Observation vs. Vitrectomy for Floaters

Kyle Kovacs, MD; Matthew Starr, MD; and Nita Valikodath, MD

Racial/Ethnic Disparities in TDR, DME, and Other Vision Threats in Patients With DR

Jordan Deaner, MD; Rehan Hussain, MD; and Vaidehi Dedania, MD

GLP-1 Use and AMD Risk

Barton Blackorby, MD, Katharine Talcott, MD, and Hong-Uyen Hua, MD

Outcomes for PDR Patients LTFU for at Least 1 Year

Kyle Kovacs, MD; Matt Starr, MD; and Nita Valikodath, MD, MS

Diagnosis Delays in Stargardt Disease

Alexis Warren, MD; Jesse Sengillo, MD; and Sruthi Arepalli, MD

Assessing Surgical Competency Among Retina Fellows: Perspectives from Directors and Graduates

Nikisha Kothari, MD; Jesse Sengillo, MD; and Nicholas Farber, MD

Endophthalmitis Rates With and Without Antibiotic Prophylaxis

Alexis Warren, MD; Sruthi Arepalli, MD; and Jesse Sengillo, MD

Time-Driven Cost Analysis of PRP: Dollars, Minutes, and Patient Care

Niki Kothari, MD; Jesse Sengillo, MD; and Nicholas Farber, MD

Aflibercept 8 mg in nAMD: Outcomes After Switching From Faricimab

Ben Young, MD; Pheobe Mellen, MD; and Jordan Deaner, MD

Obstructive Sleep Apnea and Diabetic Retinopathy

Lediana Goduni, MD; Alexis Warren, MD; and Joshua Uhr, MD

Diabetic Retinopathy Severity and Income Status

Ben Young, MD; Phoebe Mellen, MD; and Jordan Deaner, MD

Photobiomodulation for Age-related Macular Degeneration

Barton Blackorby, MD; Hong-Uyen Hua, MD; and Louis Cai, MD

GLP-1s and Risk of Age-Related Ocular Disease

Lediana Goduni, MD; Alexis Warren, MD; and Joshua Uhr, MD

Fellow Eye RRD Risk per IRIS Registry

Barton Blackorby, MD, Louis Cai, MD, and Hong-Uyen Hua, MD

Rates of Ocular AEs After Faricimab Injection

Maura Di Nicola, MD; Sruthi Arepalli, MD; and Barton Blackorby, MD

Switching from Aflibercept to Faricimab in Wet AMD Patients

Ben Young, MD, MS; Lediana Goduni, MD; and Joshua Uhr, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club w/ VBS: Does Metformin Reduce AMD Risk?

Moderator Rebecca Soares, MD; Matt Starr, MD; and Nikisha Kothari, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club with VBS: Pre-treatment with Chlorhexidine vs. Povidone-Iodine in Endophthalmitis Prevention

Maura Di Nicola, MD; Sruthi Arepalli, MD; and Barton Blackorby, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club w/ VBS: Risk of Death, Stroke, and MI After RAO

Katherine Talcott, MD; Kyle Kovacs, MD; and Phoebe Mellen, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club with VBS: Switching to Faricimab in Wet AMD Patients With a History of Anti-VEGF Therapy

Ben Young, MD, MS; Lediana Goduni, MD; and Josh Uhr, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club w/ VBS: Risk Factors for Switching from Bevacizumab to Aflibercept in Protocol AC

Rebecca Soares, MD; Matt Starr, MD; and Nikisha Kothari, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club w/ VBS: RVOs During the COVID Pandemic

Katherine Talcott, MD; Phoebe Mellen, MD and Kyle Kovacs, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club with VBS: Is Buckling Effective for RRD in Patients at Risk for PVR?

David Xu, MD, Barton Blackorby, MD, and Prethy Rao, MD, MPH

New Retina Radio Journal Club with VBS: Comparison of Antiseptics Use for IVT

Sruthi Arepalli, MD, Vaidehi Dedania, MD, and Rebecca Soares, MD, MPH

New Retina Radio Journal Club with VBS: Visual Outcomes Following Surgical RRD Repair Relative to Foveal Status and Time of Surgery

Lediana Goduni, MD; Matthew R. Starr, MD; and Joshua H. Uhr, MD

Intentional Suspension of Therapy in Wet AMD

Sruthi Arepalli, MD, Rebecca Soares, MD, MPH, and Vaidehi Dedania, MD

Prophylactic Laser for Lattice Degeneration in Fellow Eyes After RRD Repair

David Xu, MD, Prethy Rao, MD, and Barton Blackorby, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Are Postpartum Retinal Detachment Rates Linked to Method of Delivery?

Lediana Goduni, MD, Matt Starr, MD, and Joshua Uhr, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Cost Evaluation in DME Therapy

Priya Vakharia, MD, Sruthi Arepalli, MD, and Vaidehi Dedania, MD,

Meta-analysis of PPV for Diabetic TRD

Katherine Talcott, MD, Kyle Kovacs, MD, and Rebecca Soares, MD, MPH,

Is Software on Home OCT as Good as Human Graders?

Sabin Dang, MD, Lediana Goduni, MD, and Prethy Rao, MD, MPH

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Wet AMD: Fluid-free Visits' Association with Anatomic and Visual Outcomes

Katherine Talcott, MD; Kyle Kovacs, MD; and Rebecca Soares, MD, MPH

New Retina Radio Journal Club: AMD and Depression Risk

Lediana Goduni, MD; and Prethy Rao, MD, MPH

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Duration of Macular Detachment and Final Visual Prognosis

Priya Vakharia, MD, Sruthi Arepalli, MD, and Vaidehi Dedania, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Profiling Punctate Inner Choroidopathy-like Reactions

Yasha Modi, MD; Kyle Kovacs, MD; and Priya Vakharia, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Biosimilars in Retina: A Pair of Phase 3 Papers

Yasha Modi, MD; Kyle Kovacs, MD; Priya Vakharia, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Latest Literature in Stickler Syndrome and GRTs

Yoshi Yonekawa, MD, PhD; Peter Campbell, MD; Karen Jeng-Miller, MD; and Prethy Rao, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Updates in ROP

Yoshi Yonekawa, MD, PhD; Peter Campbell, MD; Karen Jeng-Miller, MD; and Prethy Rao, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Multifocal, Indolent, Nonprogressive Choroidal Lesions

Kyle D. Kovacs, MD; Cynthia Qian, MD; and David Xu, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Recurrent RRD Management

Kyle Kovacs, MD; Cynthia Qian, MD; David Xu, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Pentosan Polysulfate Maculopathy

Basil Williams, MD; Karen Jeng-Miller, MD, MPH; M. Ali Khan, MD; and Katherine Talcott, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Trends in Retina Reimbursement

Eric D. Nudleman, MD, PhD; Thanos Papakostas, MD; John B. Miller, MD; and Priya Sharma Vakharia, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Diversity in Clinical Trials

Basil Williams, MD; Karen Jeng-Miller, MD, MPH; M. Ali Khan, MD; and Katherine Talcott, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club: PPV vs PnR for RRD

Eric Nudleman, MD, PhD; John Miller, MD; Thanos Papakostas, MD; and Priya Vakharia, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Medical Management of Macular Holes

Christina Y. Weng, MD, MBA; Brian K. Do, MD; and Mrinali Gupta, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Treating CMV with Adoptive Immunotherapy

Christina Weng, MD, MBA; Mrinali Gupta, MD; Brian Do, MD, and Dimitra Skondra, MD, PhD

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Exudative AMD in FILLY and GATHER1 Results

Aleksandra Rachitskaya, MD; Emmanuel Chang, MD, PhD; Michael Klufas, MD; and Dmitra Skondra, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Data in the Wake of COVID-19

Caroline Baumal, MD; M. Ali Khan, MD; Vlad Matei, MD; and Christina Weng, MD, MBA

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Masking in Retina: Keeping Patients Safe from Bacterial Exposure

Yoshihiro Yonekawa, MD; Jonathan Chang, MD; Ajay E. Kuriyan, MD, MS; and Paula Pecen, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Autologous Retina Transplant for Macular Holes

Caroline Baumal, MD; M. Ali Khan, MD; Vlad Matei, MD; and Christina Weng, MD, MBA

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Protocol W: How Might the Data Change Practice?

Yoshihiro Yonekawa, MD; Ajay Kuriyan, MD; Anton Orlin, MD; and Paula Pecen, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club: PRO Study Group Papers: Part 2

Jayanth Sridhar, MD; Brian Do, MD; Sabin Dang, MD; Avni P. Finn, MD, MBA

New Retina Radio Journal Club: PRO Study Group Papers: Part 1

Jayanth Sridhar, MD; Brian K. Do, MD; and Avni Finn, MD, MBA

New Retina Radio Journal Club: OCT Biomarkers in New Onset GA

Yoshihiro Yonekawa, MD; Marion Munk, MD, PhD; Lejla Vajzovic, MD; David Xu, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Anti-VEGF vs Surgery + PRP for VH with PDR

Aleksandra Rachitskaya, MD; Mrinali Gupta, MD; Eric Nudleman, MD, PhD; and Aris Thanos, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Phase 2 LADDER Study Data

Aleksandra Rachitskaya, MD; Mrinali Gupta, MD; Eric Nudleman, MD, PhD; and Aris Thanos, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Imaging Modalities in DR

Jorge Fortun, MD; Cynthia Qian, MD; Christina Weng, MD, MBA; and Basil Williams, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Intravitreal Dexamethasone Implant in DME Patients

Host Jorge Fortun, MD; Cynthia Qian, MD; Christina Weng, MD, MBA; and Basil Williams, MD

New Retina Radio Journal Club: Putting the Fun Back in Journal Club

Basil K. Williams Jr., MD, Christina Weng, MD, MBA, Cynthia Qian, MD, John Kitchens, MD, Jorge Fortun, MD

Back to All Videos